Use this 401(k) investing strategy to calm your market jitters

Investors who are skittish about the ups and downs of the stock market can borrow an easy 401(k) investment strategy to calm their nerves and be more disciplined with their money — and reap the potential financial benefits.

The strategy is called “dollar-cost averaging.”

It entails investing money in equal tranches and at regular intervals, regardless of what’s happening in the market. Those who participate in workplace retirement plans like a 401(k) do this perhaps without even knowing, since a portion of each paycheck is invested automatically.  

More from Personal Finance:
How retirees can protect nest eggs during a stock market rout
How to capture higher savings yields with a CD ladder
Young investors are selling stocks and using retirement savings for emergencies

Here’s an example of how it works from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority: Let’s say you’ve saved $10,000 or received a $10,000 bonus. With dollar-cost averaging, you’d invest that money over time (perhaps by investing $1,000 a month for 10 months) instead of doing it all at once as a $10,000 lump sum.

Among the primary benefits of dollar-cost averaging: It strips the emotion out of investing.

“Doing a little bit over time will average out the good days and bad days [in the market] and make it a more palatable experience for you,” said Sean Deviney, a certified financial planner based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.

Emotion can be a toxic force for investors. For example, the fear of losing money can trigger harmful behavior like trying to time the market, akin to guessing the best time to buy and sell.

Unfortunately, those efforts “often backfire,” according to Finra.

People often sell out of fear when stocks decline in value, and then miss out on potential gains when stocks rebound, the regulator said. For example, the S&P 500 stock index lost almost 20% last year, its worst showing since 2008. Investors who sold out have missed a roughly 12% gain so far in 2023.

Conversely, people might rush in when stocks surge — and buy right before stocks are about to drop.

There are all sorts of reasons to be nervous these days, like ongoing war in Ukraine and a potential recession on the horizon.

“There’s always going to be a reason not to invest,” said Deviney, director at Provenance Wealth Advisors. “If you’re always looking at a reason not to invest, you’re missing out on long-term wealth accumulation. Dollar-cost averaging makes that a little bit easier.”

The strategy can also help minimize regret. Investing smaller sums of money in chunks makes it easier to stomach a poorly timed investment, according to Charles Schwab.

However, dollar-cost averaging isn’t always the best move, or necessarily right for everyone.

Investors who can withstand the urge to sell during ugly times may get higher long-term returns by investing with a lump sum instead of spreading that sum out in pieces, according to Finra. This assumes the investor is holding that sum as cash, which generally yields lower returns than stocks over time.

Dollar-cost averaging may also mean more fees for investors if they incur a cost for each transaction, Finra said.